Where your injury case is all that matters

Illinois man says tavern failed to protect him from bar fight

A negligent party who inflicts direct damage upon a victim faces possible criminal and civil charges. A customer injured at a commercial establishment also may claim damages from a property owner who does not prevent a patron's injury.

A Southwestern Illinois case illustrates how a third party may be held accountable in a premises liability lawsuit. The plaintiff entered a Lenzburg bar late last year, where a pair of intoxicated patrons got into a fist fight. The brawling men allegedly turned on the uninvolved customer.

The victim claims punches and facial kicks that he suffered created a disabling medical condition that physically and financially impacted him. On top of medical expenses for hospitalization and facial surgery, the bar patron lost work income and was disfigured. Almost a year after the incident, the plaintiff still experiences vision problems that preclude pursuit of a "normal" life.

The $200,000-plus lawsuit accused the owner of the tavern of inadequate security, even after the bartender realized the noisy, drunk patrons posed a danger. The claim alleges that rather than calling police immediately or working to deescalate the situation, the bartender - the target of a glass thrown by one of the fighters - hurled provocative words that incited more violence.

A commercial property owner owes a customer a "reasonable" duty of care, which includes sufficient protection from assaults. Security concerns encompass, but aren't limited to, the size of a staff, the presence of a security guard, the use of on-site cameras or the failure to install proper lighting.

Evidence of security negligence must be concrete for liability claims to result in damage awards. For that reason, personal injury attorneys advise victims to seek legal assistance as soon as possible following an injury, when proof and witness statements are fresh and most easily attainable.

Compensation for premises liability claims may cover a victim's financial losses, as well as physical and emotional suffering.

Source:, "Lenzburg tavern sued by patron claiming he was punched in face" Kelly Holleran, Nov. 11, 2013

  1. "Committed To My Cause"

    I was struck by a car while cycling and severely, almost fatally injured. A team of excellent medical professionals performed complicated and extensive surgical and medical procedures as part of a successful effort to restore my health....
    -Jeff D.

  2. "Could not have made a better choice"

    We found Mark [Mathys] through the web after an auto accident in October 2011. While selecting someone you don't know to represent you can be a gamble, we could not have made a better choice....
    - Dave

  3. "Very satisfied"

    Mark [Mathys] is very professional. He responds almost immediately, via email, to any question, comment or concern I have and if he is not able to respond right away, he will let me know. I have been very satisfied with Mark so far and I am happy to be his client.

  4. "Easy to talk to"

    Mr. Mathys and Mr. Schneid were very professional and easy to talk to. Prior to working with them, my wife and I had no real experience with the legal system beyond a house closing, yet Mr. Mathys and Mr. Schneid explained the whole process to us very well. I knew that whenever I had a concern about our case or the legal system in general I could call their office or send an email and receive answers the same day... -Larry

  5. "Provided very wise advice"

    I've dealt with attorneys on a variety of issues, almost all of them since leaving college and entering the workplace. Mr. Mathys was the first attorney I had any real experience with, and I was impressed then and remain so. He provided very wise advice and always kept me informed. In the end, he delivered a favorable result. I recommend him highly.
    - Tyler D.

  6. "In-depth knowledge of the law"

    Mark [Schneid] is an excellent and skilled attorney and demonstrated in-depth knowledge of the law when he helped settle my dog bite lawsuit resulting from a traumatic incident. He explained what was needed of me and how I should handle the situation in a professional manner.
    - Karen K.

  7. "They went to bat for me"

    Not long ago I was involved in a car accident where I was hit by a gravel truck at an intersection. After I called Mathys & Schneid, even though I didn't have a very large case, they made me feel like I was one of their most important cases. They went to bat for me with the trucking company's insurance and got me a settlement. I would definitely recommend them to my family and friends. -Dan H.



We’ll review your case at NO COST TO YOU. And, you don’t pay any fees unless we win your case. Contact us today.

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.


Privacy Policy

Main Office

Law Offices of Mathys & Schneid
1730 Park Street
Suite 209
Naperville, IL 60563

Phone: 630-848-9294
Fax: 630-428-0044
Map & Directions

Law Offices of Mathys & Schneid
212 W Washington, Suite 809
Chicago, IL 60606

Map & Directions

Chicago Office

Call button