Law Offices of Mathys & Schneid 630-848-9294Phones Answered 24 Hours A Day En Español
Menu Our Offices

Illinois man says tavern failed to protect him from bar fight

A negligent party who inflicts direct damage upon a victim faces possible criminal and civil charges. A customer injured at a commercial establishment also may claim damages from a property owner who does not prevent a patron's injury.

A Southwestern Illinois case illustrates how a third party may be held accountable in a premises liability lawsuit. The plaintiff entered a Lenzburg bar late last year, where a pair of intoxicated patrons got into a fist fight. The brawling men allegedly turned on the uninvolved customer.

The victim claims punches and facial kicks that he suffered created a disabling medical condition that physically and financially impacted him. On top of medical expenses for hospitalization and facial surgery, the bar patron lost work income and was disfigured. Almost a year after the incident, the plaintiff still experiences vision problems that preclude pursuit of a "normal" life.

The $200,000-plus lawsuit accused the owner of the tavern of inadequate security, even after the bartender realized the noisy, drunk patrons posed a danger. The claim alleges that rather than calling police immediately or working to deescalate the situation, the bartender - the target of a glass thrown by one of the fighters - hurled provocative words that incited more violence.

A commercial property owner owes a customer a "reasonable" duty of care, which includes sufficient protection from assaults. Security concerns encompass, but aren't limited to, the size of a staff, the presence of a security guard, the use of on-site cameras or the failure to install proper lighting.

Evidence of security negligence must be concrete for liability claims to result in damage awards. For that reason, personal injury attorneys advise victims to seek legal assistance as soon as possible following an injury, when proof and witness statements are fresh and most easily attainable.

Compensation for premises liability claims may cover a victim's financial losses, as well as physical and emotional suffering.

Source:, "Lenzburg tavern sued by patron claiming he was punched in face" Kelly Holleran, Nov. 11, 2013

Awards & Associations

Multi-Million Dollar Advocates Forum Million Dollar Advocates Forum Illinois Trial Lawyers Association Illinois State Bar Association Logo Avvo Logo AAJ Logo

Main Office

Law Offices of Mathys & Schneid
1730 Park Street, Suite 209
Naperville, IL 60563

Phone: 630-848-9294
Fax: 630-428-0044
E-Mail | Naperville Law Office Map

Chicago Office

Law Offices of Mathys & Schneid
212 W Washington, Suite 809
Chicago, IL 60606

Phone: 630-848-9294
Fax: 630-428-0044
E-Mail | Chicago Law Office Map

Call Us

Phones Answered 24 Hours A Day

E-mail Us

Submit Our Short Contact Form
Review Us